Plans to reduce tax repayment claim time limits

A proposed change in tax law in this year’s Finance Bill could leave many taxpayers disadvantaged.
Currently when HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) makes an error or mistake in an individual’s tax affairs he can claim back taxes (with interest added) for the last 6 years. HMRC now wants to cut the time limit so it is only liable for repayments for the previous 4 years. This cannot be good news - not when HMRC can go back to collect tax for up to 20 years.

Losses - use them or lose them

The latest Finance Bill aims to counteract the use of “artificial” arrangements on trade losses by restricting loss relief to £25,000 if an individual “trades” in a non-active capacity (i.e. spends an average of under 10 hours a week on the commercial activities of that trade). It therefore seems a good time to look at what other loss relief is allowable.

Commerciality test
As a basic test, a tax loss is not available for relief unless the trade is carried on on a commercial basis, with a view to the realisation of profit, and the trader must now prove that he is active on the trade for 10 hours a week. The following assumes this is the case.

Losses in early years
Losses incurred in the early years of a trade (i.e. the year in which the trade started, or in the next three years) may be carried back against total income for the preceding three years (earlier years first).

Pre-trading expenditure is relieved as if it has been incurred on first day of trading.

Offset trading loss against capital gain
Any trading loss that is potentially allowable against total income can also be offset against a capital gain where the loss exceeds your total income for the year.

Property losses
An excess of property expenses over rents creates property losses. These losses can be offset against current or future property income.

Capital losses
Capital losses can be used against capital gains of the same year or carried forward.
Losses can only be carried back on death, when a three-year carry back is allowed.

Disposal to a connected person
Where a capital tax loss arises on such a disposal, it can only be offset against gains on disposals to the same connected person.

Negligible value
If an asset has become negligible in value, a claim can be made such that the asset is treated as having been sold and immediately reacquired thus generating a loss. “Negligible” is not defined by statute but HMRC’s view is that the term means “worth next to nothing”.

Budget 2008 - Previously announced

Much of what will be included in this year’s Finance Bill was known long before the Chancellor stood up to make his Budget speech. The main items of relevance to businesses are summarised here, with links to earlier postings:-

  • Corporation Tax – from 1 April 2008 the main rate will be reduced from 30% to 28% and the small companies’ rate increased from 20% to 21%. 
  • Homes abroad owned through a company – removal of a benefit in kind tax charge where the company is owned by individuals and the sole activity of the company is to hold an overseas property for occupation by the individuals and/or letting. 
  • Loss Relief – restriction of loss relief for interest payments made on certain qualifying loans in a partnership or a small company. Effective from 9 October 2007 this measure tackles a tax avoidance scheme which sought to advance the time at which relief could be claimed.
  • CGT reform for individuals & trusts (not for companies) – abolition of indexation allowances and taper relief, and introduction of a flat rate of 18%, (subject to new entrepreneurs’ relief) from 6 April 2008.
  • Research & Development – extension of SME tax relief schemes to include mid-sized companies with fewer than 500 employees.
  • Company gains on life policies – to be brought within the loan relationship legislation.
  • Capital Allowances – a range of new measures, including the reduction of annual writing down allowances to 20%, introduction of an Annual Investment Allowance of £50,000 and the reduction in the rate of allowances available for integral fixtures.
  • Leased plant & machinery – changes to bring the proceeds of sale from finance leaseback arrangement into charge to tax, and other anti-avoidance changes to long funding lease rules.