Is bartering the way forward?

Bartering is a growing trend particularly with cash restrictions in the recession. But the fact that no cash changes hands does not necessarily mean no tax impact.

For VAT both parties have to agree a reasonable value for their services, and assuming they are both registered, must issue an invoice for VAT purposes only.  Assuming the services exchanged are of equal value input = output = no cash, if not there is a liability.

For income or corporation tax, provided the services exchanged are of equal value the income notionally received is cancelled out by the costs notionally payable, otherwise, again an adjustment is required.

As ever, proper documentation is key.

Cathy Corns is a tax adviser and a partner at Mercer & Hole. The views given in this blog are personal to the author, if you would like to discuss the contents of this blog with Cathy you can call her on 01908 605552.

Changes to compliance checks

The Finance Act 2008 has introduced a number of changes to compliance which will take effect from 1 April 2009.

The main changes are:

  • HMRC will have one set of powers covering PAYE, VAT, Income Tax, Corporation Tax, Capital Gains Tax and Construction Industry Scheme to visit and inspect businesses and records and to request information and documents
  • Greater flexibility in setting record keeping requirements
  • New time limits
  • Safeguards for taxpayers

For VAT, the time limits for assessments and claims will be increased from three to four years. The legislation ensures that claims that are already out of time are not brought back into time.

HMRC has published an e-learning package on its website. This sets out the new framework in more detail.
 

New penalties for errors on tax returns and documents

HMRC has published new guidance on the new penalty provisions that will apply from April 2008.

HMRC states that it has designed the new penalties so that:

  • If people take reasonable care when completing their returns they will not be penalised.
  • If they do not take reasonable care errors will be penalised, and the penalties will be higher if the error is deliberate.
  • Disclosing errors before HMRC find them will substantially reduce any penalty due.

The new penalties initially apply to VAT, PAYE, National Insurance, Capital Gains Tax, Income Tax, Corporation Tax and the Construction Industry Scheme.

Further information can be found at:
http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/about/new-penalties/penalties-leaflet.pdf
http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/about/new-penalties/faqs.htm  

Budget 2008 - Corporation tax simplification...

…but don’t hold your breath; the proposals, when formulated, will only apply to companies with less than 10 employees and turnover under £750,000. This may not be quite what most SMEs were hoping for.

The new all tax penalty regime...

... is expected to take effect for periods starting after 31 March 2008 where the return is filed after 31 March 2009.

The new system distinguishes between different types of tax “offence” for example, heavy penalties for evasion, but an acknowledgement that genuine errors happen.

HMRC appears to want to encourage compliance and sees penalties as an essential element in enforcement.

The result is that the new penalties will apply to returns for income tax, corporation tax, pay as you earn, national insurance contributions and VAT.

The new regime seeks to grade the penalty to match the ‘offence’. There are effectively four categories:

  • Innocent mistake; 
  • Careless conduct; 
  • Deliberate action, but not concealed; and 
  • Deliberate action with concealment.

Innocent mistakes will no longer attract a penalty. The penalties for the other three conducts are laid down with prescribed reductions for disclosure (differentiating between prompted and unprompted). The proposed penalties range from 15% to 30%, for a prompted disclosure for ‘failure to take reasonable care’, to 100% of the tax due for a ‘deliberate understatement with concealment’.

It will be “interesting” to see how HMRC will distinguish between innocent mistakes and a ‘failure to take reasonable care’. This is likely to be an area for debate, dispute and potential litigation.
You should be aware that unprompted disclosures will reduce penalties to nil for potentially minor offences.

Additionally, in cases of ‘failure to take reasonable care’, HMRC has the discretion to apply a suspended penalty. If the correct procedure is implemented and adhered to, the penalty could be cancelled.

One thing that is clear is that a lot of businesses and individuals will be affected.

Do you know who your company is associated with?

Companies pay corporation tax at 20% on the first £300,000, right? Wrong! A company pays at 20% of the first £300,000 divided equally between it and its associates.

Companies are associated where:

·         one of the companies has control of the other, or

·         both of the companies are under the control of the same person(s).

A person controls a company if he is entitled to >50% of:

·         the share capital, or votes;

·         the distributions to shareholders;

·         the assets on winding up (this includes loan creditors).

The problem is that when looking at control you have to take account of a person’s associates. These are:

·         spouse (includes separated, but not divorced) and civil partner

·         parents, grand parents and remoter forebear

·         brother or sister, including half siblings (but not step, aunts, uncles or cousins)

·         partner (as in a business partnership)

·         settlements and will trust associates; - trustees are associated where the individual, or any living or dead relative is or was the settler; and where the individual is interested in a settlement, then beneficiaries, remainder men and trustees are associates.

Under self-assessment it is your responsibility to make sure your company pays the right amount of tax.

So – are you sure you know all your company’s associates?